shammah98

Cloud Backup Suggestion

14 posts in this topic

I have an HP Mediasmart 485v3. Just put in a new seagate 2TB in my 4th bay. I have a 2TB, 1TB, and 750GB (system) drive in the other bays. all filled up. I have duplication turned on (it essentially is my music/photo/video server). I regularly use the built in backup tool to back up the server to an external hitachi HD (3TB). It is my understaning that this only backs up the shares, so i just installed BDBB, which i will use to back up the server files to the external drive as well.

For an additional/last layer of redundancy, I want to get some offsite/online back up as well. I searched the forums and i saw cloudberry, using amazon s3 The simplicity of this appealed to me, but when i checked on amazon's price estimator, it was quoting me $700/yr for my approx 4TB of data. seems too expensive for me.

Does anyone have any experience with KeepVault or any other cloud backup service that works with WHSv1?

Thanks. and Happy New Year!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Upgrade to a WGS Supporter Account to remove this ad.

Maybe this will help... http://lifehacker.co...limited-backups

Personally speaking, I don't see how you'd get 4TB uploaded to the cloud, unless they provide a service to allow you to send them one (or more) physical drives to pre-load into your account. Even a 100Mbps internet connection would take a very, very long time.

For the individual person trying to protect their movies and music, the original files, plus duplication with an additional set of backup drives is probably sufficient (that's 3 copies of each file). If you're really that paranoid, you'd be better served with an additional couple large drives that clone the backup set. You could keep those off-site someplace.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Think how long that amount of data is going to take to transfer over the net zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used to have a Carbonite account for a work server. It backs up in the background, and after the first backup - which can take weeks, it only backs up incrementally.

Might be worth a look.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I guess the other issue I see with cloud backup is that it would also take maybe weeks to get your 4TB of stuff back, if you ever needed it. I think the cloud concept is great for user generated data, or maybe even the average person's home computer. I'm not sure I see the realistic value for servers full of movies.

Businesses who use this technology are not using the cable company's broadband internet service...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally, I think that the cloud might be good for a few GBs of critical data at most. Other, less critical data can be backud up to a NAS installed maybe in another room using a gigabit connection.

Just to put things into perspective, transferring 4TBs of data over a 2mbps line would take roughly 180 days or 6 months!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks OJ. I was too lazy to do the math. :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks everyone for the replies. Yeah I knew it would take a long time to upload that amount of data. And actually, upon further thought, I realized I would only be uploading our family videos/pics and personal docs. So it wouldn't be anywhere close to the 4TB (Maybe 1?) Funny how one forgets about the hard copies of their music/video library after using digital media for so long. You'd think I'd remember considering how long it took to rip them all to the server! :-)

Using duplication, the space goes 2x as fast. IN the mediasmart servers, we're limited to 4bays. ONce those get filled up, do you just start adding external HDs?

thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think you'll get a bigger bag for the buck by adding multi-drive enclosures, instead of single, external drives. All the MSS's except for the EX48x series have PM Aware eSATA connections.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm in the exact same boat here. I'm running an Acer home server and although I've got around 2 or 3 TB of data, I only want to back up about 1TB worth to the cloud (documents, family photos and home videos). I had signed up for Asus Webstorage a while back (like over 2 years ago) and to this day have still not finished my first full backup. I recently upgraded my home Internet connection to 5Mbps upstream, but I was dismayed to find out that it doesn't matter because Asus Webstorage caps the upload bandwidth to 500Kbps or less!!! Anyway, it's really dirt cheap, i.e. 55 bucks for 2 years of unlimited storage, so I just let it run in the background. But if anyone has any other suggestions for cheap cloud storage (to have in addition to internal duplication and external backups) I'd love to hear it! Backblaze is cheap but doesn't support server OS, and the ones that do are pretty expensive. Yes, I'm paranoid like that, I've lost data before...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cloud Backup Services providing mostly secure and reliable storage and backup platform. But i recommend only Dropbox, sugarsync, livedrive and other best cloud backup services. I rate cloud backup services on the basis of their features rather pricing plans. I strongly recommend to select provider who have following features: Synchronization, file versioning, file preview, restored deleted files, fully automated, incremental backup, can be able to access from any part of the world. All the above mentioned providers does have these features. For the secure cloud backup service these features need to look at before making any final decision. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know cloud is all the rage, but how about an external drive (or two) backed up on a weekly or monthly basis and taken offsite (to work, a friend's house)?

 

I have yet to find an offsite backup service that copies files fast enough, is trustworthy, doesn't cost a lot, can handle file deltas (instead of always re-transferring an entire file if only part of it has changed) - and allows me to quickly pull back down my backed up data for a restore.

 

I'm a backup freak and have a crazy amount of redundancies within the home.  But without offsite backup too, a fire would wipe it all out.  Since I haven't found an automatic, hands-free option that meets my criteria (above), I have a calendar reminder each month to backup my critical files to an external drive.  When my monthly reminder fires, I backup to an external and take it to work with me the next day.  That gives me a copy offsite in another city - and allows a super-quick, local restore from the external drive if needed.

 

I used to hack CrashPlan to copy my WHS data to a friend's WHS (and vice versa), but the external drive via sneakernet works better than anything else I've found to date.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

SyncToy maybe? Or a scripted RoboCopy?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now



Upgrade to a WGS Supporter Account to remove this ad.



  • Posts

    • The experience I have had with Storage Spaces has not been good. I had a disk go bad and even though I had redundant storage set up, the system did not rebuild all the stored folders completely and I had to resort to other backups that I kept on another server. Note that Storage Space data is not recoverable if the system goes bad. Drivepool still has the files fully readable just like the old duplication system in WHS V1. 
    • I get the above error dialogue when I run the connector on my Win 10 pro client.  Followed the issue resolution on TechNet which say start cert service in IIS on server but this was already running.   I've downloaded the Win 10 connector with no joy also.   Please help.
    • Dave, can you clarify what you mean by this?
    • I had no problem with Windows 10.  However, I just completed the anniversary update and now the "Connector" won't run to conclusion.  It backs itself out and reports an unspecified error.
    • Apologies if I'm being stupid, but I'm having great trouble understanding how Lightsout backup and the Server Essentials 2012 backup work together (or fight with each other). I find the Lightsout documentation on this very unclear, and various threads have left me no wiser. I'd appreciate some help! Here's the setup: Lightsout is running nicely on the server. Before backups were set up, I established that the server hibernated when the clients were switched off. The server woke up when a client was powered up. (This behaviour broke when backups were set up.) The server is Essentials 2012, with a number of client laptops: a mix of Windows 7, 8 & 10. The Essentials backup window is 22:00 - 07:00. No backup settings are currently made in Lightsout. Here's what I'd like to achieve: At the end of the working day all the clients are put to sleep or hibernate (or switched off completely, I don't care which). Ten minutes after that, Lightsout hibernates the server. Sometime during the night (22:00 - 07:00) the server wakes up, then wakes up the various clients in turn, backs them up, and puts them back to sleep / hibernate / shutdown (I don't care which). Here's what actually happens (when I look at the uptime chart the next morning): At the end of the day (about 17:15) the clients are put to sleep / hibernate. (I tell the team not to shut down their client laptops because I assume the server can't wake a completely shut down client - is that correct?) The server does not hibernate. Approximately 90 minutes after the clients were put to sleep / hibernate, they all wake up simultaneously (around 18:45, but I don't know why this happens). The clients then stay awake all night. Later, from 22:00, some of the backups take place (but not all of them). The backups are spread wide apart in the 22:00 - 07:00 window with lots of time when nothing is going on at all. The clients do not go back to sleep / hibernate after their backups. ...can anyone suggest what combination of settings I should be using to get the desired behaviour? Here are the sort of things that are confusing me, but I can't find definitive answers (and each experiment I do takes 24 hours to give any results!): I know I can specify clients' individual backup times in Lightsout, but I don't know how long a client's backup will take, so I could have backups overlapping each other and causing a traffic jam. Should I worry about this? If I set Lightsout backups, what do I set for the Essentails backup window? What if it's not long enough to get all the backups done? If I make settings in the Lightsout backup dialog do I have to complete everything in that dialog box? Does this make the Essentials 2012 backup settings redundant? What about the Essentials 22:00 - 07:00 backup window, does that matter any more? I tried setting client backup times in Lightsout with an end action of 'sleep'. The backups didn't happen at all and clients all spontaneously went to sleep in the middle of the working day (the server / clients clocks all match, I checked). Can Lightsout wake up a client laptop that is completely shut down? Thanks for reading this long post and sorry if these seem like stupid questions. I already have WHS2011 / Lightsout running perfectly on another setup (where my backups take place during the day), but nocturnal backups are a new level of complexity for me!
  • Popular Contributors